Intro to Katie 101

You think you know, but you have no idea……..

Inspiration of a Muse

To choose one scene to answer a focusing question is pretty tough when it comes to Dogma.  Every scene has some sort of flip-flop (ha! a dash!) of what the majority of us have been taught to believe.  My focusing question is why Kevin Smith used women to portray roles in the movie that are otherwise known as men?  I think I’ll choose the scene when they meet the Muse because that particular scene really spells out what is going on up to that point. 

Bethany and her entourage have arrived at a Strip Club, out of all places, to find a muse named Serendipity.  She explains that she has come down to get credit for her inspirations, but finds out that she cannot use her inspiration for personal gain.  So she finds herself a womanly host body and a job as a stripper because at least she can make a buck or two.  When she meets her new found friends she gives an explaination as to why things the way they are.  She starts talking and keeps using “She” in reference to God.  She stops to explain that when she wrote the story of the Bible (remember she is the muse, so she didn’t physically write it) that she meant for God to be a woman.  The men that she inspired to write the Bible were all men and took it upon themselves to change Her into a Him.

I think this will be a strong point to mention because not only was God meant to be a woman and is portrayed as a woman in this movie, but the last Scion is a woman, and the inspiration for all creation is portrayed as a woman, too!  Alison made a good point as well.  A muse is never mentioned in the Bible.  It could be that Kevin Smith created one because society was taught that we were created from amebas, the Big Bang theory, or as the Bible begins in Genesis “God created Heven and Earth……”  He may have wanted to create his own beginning to creation, but as with all projects, they have to comes from ideas.  To keep with the theme of biblical anarchy, he made the inspiration of creation a woman.

P.S.  I’ll try not to make this a super feminist paper……..

Advertisement

2 Comments»

  kylefagan wrote @

This is a very controversal topic that I had to learn about when I took confermation when I was in Gradeschool. Now im going to try and agrue this with what I was taught by the church (they can be pretty stubborn). In Genisis it was told that man was made in the image of God, to look and act like him. The first person we learn about is Adam who named all the animals but could not find a suitable creature to be his mate, his companion to rule over the land that God had given them. God took out a rib of Adam as he slept and then created Eve, who was a woman. So according to the bible God could not have been a woman. Once again that is according to the way that the church views it. Hopefully this helps you with your essay trying to prove the church wrong..

  jmacniak wrote @

Maybe it’s a big joke on feminism. Even though he chooses women as the significant characters in the movie, he makes them silly at the same time. The muse who was the insiration for all man kind chooses to be a stripper? God runs around in tutu acting like a princess….HELLO! YOU’RE GOD!!! why would you want to be a princess? and the women who carries the child descendent of Christ is an athiest who works at an abortion clinic? Well that last one does seem like it would be good religious irony in any movie. Maybe it all lies in the titel Dogma: a doctrine or body of doctrines concerning faith or morals formally stated and authoritatively proclaimed by a church. and the fact that he made it in as a feminist would with women controling all the major religious rolls, but he made it a complete joke.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.